Many organisations find it challenging to assess the true impact of their learning and development (L&D) programmes. Without effective evaluation, it’s difficult to know what’s working and what needs improvement. Regularly reviewing your evaluation processes and ensuring they align with your strategic goals can help you get more value from your L&D efforts. Curious about how to take a more strategic approach? Read on for top tips to enhance your training evaluation and unlock greater success.
Reading time: 4 minutes
Did you know that only 8% of CEOs see the business impact of their L&D programmes, and fewer than 4% have a clear sense of ROI? These figures are a stark reminder than we need to rethink how we evaluate the effectiveness of training.
Effective monitoring and evaluation are the keys to driving successful learning and development (L&D) strategies. Without a clear view of what’s working and what’s not, it’s hard to make informed decisions or justify L&D investments. In fact, our 2024 L&D Roadmap shows that fewer than 30% of organisations can confidently prove ROI, meaning many of us are missing valuable opportunities to fine-tune our programmes and achieve better results.
Your organisation likely has evaluation processes in place, but when was the last time you reviewed them? Are these processes aligned with your current strategic goals? More importantly, do they drive real impact?
It’s easy to rely on familiar, tried-and-tested methods. However, sometimes a fresh perspective can uncover more effective approaches. Take a step back and explore our top tips for enhancing your training evaluation process - it could be the key to unlocking greater success.
Curious about how to take a more strategic approach to training evaluation? Keep reading to discover how to get the most out of your L&D programmes.
1. Shift from measuring ROI to ROE (Return on Expectations)
When we talk about ROE (Return on Expectations), it’s about looking beyond just financial returns. Instead of focusing solely on numbers, ROE is a more holistic framework that evaluates how well training aligns with the bigger picture - organisational goals and what really matters to your stakeholders.
This approach goes deeper, capturing outcomes that might be less tangible but equally important - things like shifts in culture, leadership development, or sparking innovation.
These are the kinds of changes that align more closely with long-term strategy and can demonstrate how training contributes to business transformation in ways that traditional ROI measurement may not show.
Say you’ve implemented a new leadership development programme. You might not see an immediate boost in financial results, but you can measure success by looking at improved leadership effectiveness and increased employee engagement - key metrics that reflect your stakeholders' expectations. That’s where ROE really comes into play.
It’s important to identify and engage key stakeholders early on. Ask them what success looks like from their perspective and work together to define measurable outcomes that align with these expectations.
Design your evaluation framework to track both short-term results and longer-term impacts, like follow-up assessments, performance reviews and ongoing stakeholder feedback. This way, you’re not just checking boxes but truly measuring how training is driving meaningful change over time.
2. Enhance your evaluation strategy through systems thinking
Using systems thinking in training evaluation gives you a bigger picture of how your initiatives connect with different parts of the organisation, like culture, processes and technology. It’s about seeing how training impacts both individual performance and broader organisational goals. While Return on Expectations (ROE) looks at specific stakeholder outcomes, systems thinking focuses on how training fits into the organisation's interconnected elements, offering a more complete view.
To get started, map out your organisation’s ecosystem and identify the key areas that influence training outcomes. For instance, with a leadership development programme, engage with HR, operations and employee experience teams to understand how the training impacts participants, their teams and overall productivity. You may find that participants report increased confidence but communication barriers between teams limit the programme’s overall effectiveness.
With these insights, you can adjust your evaluation metrics to track not only skills development but also improvements in team collaboration and communication. This approach helps you understand how the leadership programme contributes to larger organisational goals and where there’s room for improvement.
3. Integrate scenario planning into training evaluation
To keep your training programmes agile and prepared for the future, it’s crucial to evaluate them in the context of possible future scenarios. This ensures that your learning initiatives are not just reactive but proactive, helping your organisation stay ahead of emerging challenges.
Begin by identifying key factors that could shape your organisation’s future. These might include market shifts, new technologies, or evolving customer demands. Take, for example, the L&D team at a bank transitioning to digital banking in response to fintech advancements. How can you best prepare your workforce? By mapping out best-case, worst-case, and most likely scenarios, the bank can pinpoint which skills - such as data analytics or cybersecurity - will be vital moving forward.
By setting up relevant metrics, you can track how effectively current training is equipping your team for these anticipated demands. This ensures they not only support your organisation's strategic goals today but also adapt to meet future demands.
4. Elevate evaluation through predictive analysis
While scenario planning helps prepare for multiple potential outcomes, predictive analysis focuses on leveraging historical data and analysing current industry trends. This data-driven approach forecasts specific skills requirements, enabling you to address potential gaps before they become critical.
For instance, an L&D team in the pharmaceutical industry must stay ahead of advancements in drug development, regulatory changes and emerging therapies. By using predictive analytics, they can identify essential skills and knowledge that will be necessary in the near future, such as understanding genetic therapies and biopharmaceuticals.
Regularly assess if your programmes are aligned with future trends and adjust the content as needed to keep pace with industry demands.
5. Develop a 'training portfolio' evaluation approach
Finally, take inspiration from the financial world and consider grouping your key training programmes into 'portfolios'. Much like financial portfolio management, this approach lets you assess the combined impact of your initiatives rather than viewing them in isolation.
To get started, think about the various training programmes available to your teams. For example, if you're working with a product development team, you could group training into portfolios based on key areas like design thinking, agile methodologies and user experience (UX) testing. This categorisation helps you see the bigger picture.
Next, create an overview of the programmes within each portfolio, and then define evaluation criteria and metrics. By evaluating how well each portfolio supports key business goals - such as quicker product launches or improved collaboration - you’ll uncover strengths and areas for improvement.
By adopting this approach, you can make continual adjustments to maximise the value across your learning portfolio and ensure each element effectively contributes to overall success.
Final thoughts
To truly maximise the impact of your L&D initiatives, adopting a more strategic approach to measuring and evaluating training is key. Regularly reviewing your processes and ensuring they are in line with your organisation’s goals will help you achieve more significant outcomes. By applying our recommendations, you’ll be able to design more data-driven learning strategies that not only engage participants but also deliver tangible results.
As you plan for the future, keep in mind how advancements in technology, like AI and data analytics, can provide deeper insights into learner engagement and performance. These tools can help you continuously refine your evaluation methods, ensuring your training programmes stay impactful and relevant in the long run.
British Council has 90 years’ experience of partnering with organisations and individuals in over 200 countries to upskill their workforce for success.
Our four-step process supports you to implement initiatives that make a difference and cultivate a learning culture in your organisation.
Download our Corporate English Solutions brochure or book a free consultation to learn more.